That distinction between employee and independent contractor in California is not merely a case of semantics; it is also a distinction that may result in a statewide audit by the Employment Development Department (EDD). Classification of workers is a concept that every company, whether large or small, needs to understand and implement.
What Does It Mean to Misclassify a Worker?
Misclassification is a situation where a business classified a worker as an independent contractor, but, as per the law, they are more of an employee. This normally translates to the fact that the employee does not get perks such as unemployment insurance, payroll taxes, and workers' compensation (which are all within the spectrum of the EDD).
Why Does Misclassification Trigger an EDD Audit?
The EDD checks the laws of California on labor and taxation. It starts an audit in cases where it suspects that a company is evading paying employment taxes by misclassifying its workers.
These audits are done to recover unpaid taxes and to make sure that there is compliance with the labor laws. A single wrong classification may result in high penalties and interest. An EDD audit attorney from Los Angeles can help in such situations.
What Are the Common Triggers for an EDD Audit Related to Misclassification?
The few red flags that may result in an audit are:
· An employee who has claimed unemployment or disability benefits.
· A former whistleblower contractor complaint.
· Breaches within 1099 vs. W-2.
· Random sampling in ordinary compliance checks of EDD.
When the irregularities are noted by EDD, it can initiate a full audit of previous payroll records.
How Does California Determine if a Worker Is an Employee or Contractor?
In California and particularly since the Hallmark Case of Dynamex Operations West, Inc. v. Superior Court, the major test applied is the ABC Test. Only in the following way can a worker be regarded as an independent contractor:
A. They are left without the control and guidance of the company,
B. Their work is not within the normal flow of the business of the hiring organization, and their work is not in line with the hiring organization.
C. They are involved in self-propelled trade or business.
Passing all sections of this test does not mean the worker that the legal treatment as an employee should not be offered.
What Happens If a Business Fails an EDD Audit?
In case of proven misclassification, the following may be the consequences:
· Payroll taxes and unemployment insurance back payment.
· Punishments for not withholding and paying income tax.
· An interest in unpaid sums.
· Criminal liabilities of intentional misclassification.
Companies can additionally be exposed to additional investigation by other bodies, such as the IRS or the California Labor Commissioner.
Can Businesses Defend Themselves in EDD Misclassification Audits?
Yes. Businesses can forward evidence that demonstrates the contractor's independence, e.g.:
· Agreements that indicate the character of work and the remuneration system.
· Evidence on the various clients that the contractor has worked with.
· Proof that the employee provided their equipment or managed the working hours.
It is highly recommended that an IRS and tax attorney in Los Angeles, CA, who has extensive experience in dealing with the IRS or EDD, be hired, as it will boost the chances of getting a positive outcome.
Comments